Cat Bypass/Replacement Pipe

Right, need to replace the cat (as I've destroyed the studs on the original cat), there seems to be 2 to choose from:
Straight through cat bypass from Mx5mad
http://www.mx5mad.com/product_info.php?cPath=26_31_83&products_id=227
Silenced Cat bypass from Mx5parts:
http://www.mx5parts.co.uk/product_info.php/products_id/461
They're both pretty much the same price (50 pounds, which is a bit steep), any reccomendations on which one to go for? I presume there's no difference in power gain, but does anyone have one, what's the sound like? Also, has anyone managed to find one cheaper anywhere? It's only a bit of pipe with 2 flanges, so woulnd't be surprised if it can be found cheaper somewhere.
Straight through cat bypass from Mx5mad
http://www.mx5mad.com/product_info.php?cPath=26_31_83&products_id=227
Silenced Cat bypass from Mx5parts:
http://www.mx5parts.co.uk/product_info.php/products_id/461
They're both pretty much the same price (50 pounds, which is a bit steep), any reccomendations on which one to go for? I presume there's no difference in power gain, but does anyone have one, what's the sound like? Also, has anyone managed to find one cheaper anywhere? It's only a bit of pipe with 2 flanges, so woulnd't be surprised if it can be found cheaper somewhere.